Your current locationHome page > Information dynamic  > foreign marriage return
  • Foreign lawyers team, connected at home and abroad
  • Tel: 13689535661 (Mr. Zhao)
  • WeChat: sz81197342
  • Address: 21st-26th Floor, HKCG Tower, No.4011 Shennan Avenue, Futian District, Shenzhen, China.

Divorce Cases in Cross-Border Marriages_Analysing the Jurisdictional Rules of Different Countries

source:www.zchlhls.com  |  Release time:2024年08月03日
Intercountry marriages have led to an increasing prevalence of divorce cases involving foreigners. When couples come from different countries and marry and reside in a third country, issues regarding jurisdiction arise. The following is a discussion by foreign-related lawyers on resolving different national jurisdictional issues in foreign-related divorce cases, with case examples to help readers better understand these issues.
For cross-border marriage divorce cases
Unravelling the Mystery of Jurisdiction in Foreign Divorce Cases: Foreign Lawyers Explore International Solutions

Scenario 1: The Problem of Authority in International Residence

Unravelling the Jurisdiction Puzzle in Foreign Divorce Cases: Foreign Lawyers Explore International Solutions

Jack and Alice are British citizens who got married and moved to live in France. Due to the breakdown of their marriage, they wished to divorce. However, they are faced with a problem: in which country will their divorce case be heard? France may be able to assert jurisdiction on the grounds that they are resident in France, while the UK may equally be able to assert jurisdiction as they are British citizens.

Solution:

In this case, Jack and Alice may consider applying principles of private international law, such as the law of residence, to determine the country entitled to jurisdiction over their divorce case. Often, the law of the country of residence will take precedence. They can consult legal advisors to determine the most appropriate solution while ensuring that their rights and interests are upheld.

Scenario 2: Custody of Children of Different Nationalities

Carol and David are an Italian and American couple who live in the UK and have two children. They decide to divorce, but Carol wants the children to stay in the UK, while David wants them to return to the US. This led to a dispute over custody and issues involving different national jurisdictions.

Solution:

In this situation, Carol and David can seek an international legal agreement, such as the Hague Convention for the Protection of Children, to assist in resolving child custody disputes. This convention provides a way to resolve international custody disputes and ensure that the best interests of the child are protected. Alternatively, they can negotiate an agreement that avoids long-term legal disputes and determine which country's dispute will handle the custody dispute.

Scenario 3: Divorce case in an immigrant country

Susan is a Chinese citizen who obtained permanent resident status in the United States after marrying John. They settled in the United States, but the marriage was unhappy and Susan decided to file for divorce. The question is, should they proceed with the divorce in China or the United States?

Solution:

In this case, Susan and John can negotiate an agreement to determine the country of divorce. If they are unable to reach an agreement, they can seek legal advice and decide in which country to file divorce proceedings based on the personal circumstances of both parties and the applicability of the laws of both countries.